- Ibatoulline, Bagram (2 books, 2 awards)
- Idle, Molly (1 book, 1 award)
- Ingraham, Erik (1 book, 1 award)
- Isaacson, Philip M. (1 book, 1 award)
- Isadora, Rachel (1 book, 2 awards)
- Jackson, Shelley (1 book, 1 award)
- Jacob, Murv (1 book, 1 award)
- James, Matt (2 books, 2 awards)
- Jeffers, Susan (2 books, 2 awards)
- Jenkins, Steve (3 books, 4 awards)
- Johnson, D. B. (1 book, 1 award)
- Johnson, Stephen T. (1 book, 1 award)
- Jolivet, Joelle (1 book, 1 award)
- Jonas, Ann (2 books, 2 awards)
- Jones, Bill T. (1 book, 2 awards)
- Jones, Elizabeth Orton (2 books, 2 awards)
- Jones, Noah Z. (2 books, 2 awards)
- Jorisch, Stephane (2 books, 2 awards)
- Joyner, Jerry (1 book, 1 award)